Philippe Rose
One day I'll have my office on the Moon!
Home    ▪    Archives    ▪    Gallery    ▪    About me
Home » Archives » January 2004 » Twin symmetries

[Previous entry: "War and torture"] [Next entry: "Welcome to the real world"]


14/01/2004: "Twin symmetries"


Kinder-UniExactly a week ago, I wrote on this blog of my twin disappointments of not having been able to see my favourite prof's lecture in front of 500 kids as part of Kinder-Uni, university for kids. I also wrote about my disappointment of learning of Beagle2's near-certain loss, after the failure to communicate with the probe.

Today, I was allowed a replay of both events, but with a better ending.

First, while I still wasn't allowed in the auditorium to partake of the joy of throwing paper balls around, I watched the performance on screen in an adjacent room. You could still see the paper balls quickly crossing the camera's viewing angle. While I find Kinder-Uni a great idea and encourage such initiatives with no reservation, I believe the lecture itself, while a good effort, was not the imaginative kids-friendly presentation with captivating rhetoric I had expected to hear. Surprisingly dry and dense, I caught myself day-dreaming a couple times during the 45min lecture.

However, the experience for kids is surely going to be a very positive one, if not purely for the lecture. More the chance of experiencing a university environment and being addressed directly about economic issues, a neglected topic for many of them, is bound to have a lasting impact. Cynically, one might call it a sales pitch from the capitalist academia at making future voters and potential students more receptive to the economic worldview.

Aldrin on the MoonThe second event of the day was Bush's speech at NASA. In his words: "Guided by clear objectives, today we set a new course for the American space programme," emphasizing humankind's spirit of discovery and the goal of having a human presence across the solar system, quickly and using existing programmes and personnel. Bush outlined a few key points:

▪ Completing the International Space Station by 2010
▪ Returning the Shuttle to flight asap so as to help finish the ISS
▪ Retiring the Shuttle by 2010
▪ Building a new spacecraft, the Crew Exploration Vehicle, by 2008
▪ Returning to the Moon by 2020, a launching point for missions beyond
▪ (2008 for lunar robotic missions, 2015 manned missions)
▪ Sending humans to Mars and to worlds beyond

Bush: "Human beings are headed into the Cosmos. The crew of Shuttle Columbia did not turn away from the challenge. Neither will we.

While the creation of a committee of private & public sector experts was announced with the objective of reviewiew the above goals (Pete Aldrich, chairman), and while Bush invited nations to join the US in a spirit of cooperation in this journey and not a race, the role of the private sector was not mentioned explicitly. In the article Moon-hopping to Mars in The Economist, these words:

"Ultimately, if NASA is to succeed in human space exploration, it will have to grow its budget substantially, abandon much of its other, valuable work, or ideally find a way of successfully exploiting space commercially. Until now, NASA has been spectacularly unsuccessful in this ambition because it is not designed for this purpose. Any presidential vision ought, then, to include a way of eventually wrestling space activities out of the agency’s clutches and into the hands of the private sector."



Replies: 3 Comments


on Friday, January 16th, Phil said

Press comments:

"The US is preparing for the invasion of Mars and other planets" Palestinian daily Al-Hayat Al-Jadidah

"What are the other planets chosen for the US invasion? Are they an axis of planetary evil? And what is the relationship between the regime on Pluto and fundamentalist groups?"

"The US President may figure that a pre-emptive strike against the Martians should occur while we have the size advantage" Tim Ferguson, The Age, Melbourne

"A national mission to a far-away place where glory awaits and no rebel movement lurks will help Americans forget about the continuing problems in Iraq and portray the president as a peaceful visionary." Der Standard, Austria




on Sunday, January 18th, Jon said

You seem to be having great fun keeping this blog up to date. You know I said my PC was broken, I actually meant that the motherboard was screwed. Consequently, it's gonna take another week at least before I'm back online. Hopefully chat then!

Keep planning your trip to UK after finals, and good luck with revision etc.




on Friday, March 5th, Phil said

John Glenn's sharp rebuke of Bush's new space vision was reported in today's news. The resource reallocation needed to fund the Mars-via-the-Moon trip might imply cutting scientific research that was already mostly pay for, not so much to save money but in order to "mark the change in priorities". While having a man standing on Mars is specific enough to be shown as an accomplishment (with great fanfare), the many milestones to get there will involve small (unspectacular) steps forward.

One can question if the need to show more spectacular milestones (to guarantee political support and show that the project is going forward) won't have as consequence the emphasis on resource-consuming intermediary objectives (such as building a station on the Moon) - this to garner as much political capital as possible, thus limiting resources available for the end-objective. In other words, a flag-waving press-conference on the Moon might mark the premature end to the trip to Mars.

John Glenn's criticism of Bush's space vision





Philippe Rose
Rose.ph is where Philippe Rose blogs. One day I'll have my office on the Moon (in Borneo for now).


Archives

2011: January, February, March, April, May, June
2010: January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December
2009: January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December
2008: January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December
2007: January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December
2006: January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, December
2005: January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December
2004: January, February, March, April,
May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December
2003: December

January 2004
SMTWTFS
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Shoutbox


In my ears

♫ Breed 77 ~ The Game

♫ Bullet For My Valentine ~ All These Things

♫ Creed ~ What If

♫ Matchbook Romance ~ Portrait

♫ Rise Against ~ Prayer Of The Refugee

♫ Silverstein ~ Giving Up

♫ William Shatner ~ Common People

♫ Wonderland Dementia ~ Hypnosis

♫ Radio Wazee (128k)



More blogs

Coup De
P-Manzh
Kottke.org
Indymedia
Dart Center
GMAT surfer
Registan.net
Ferghana.Ru
Disinfopedia
Ethereal Code
WorldChanging
Andrew Sullivan
Magnetic Kid Liv
David Brooks NYT
the 2011 bloggies!
Talking Points Memo
Questionable Content
Genferin und St Gallerin

#Blogging Brits?
"& .? .blog.domain .# .>




joobot

Philippe Rose
Running Greymatter | RSS